
Choosing Warehouse Automation
Find where orders wait and compare systems against the work due before dispatch.
One warehouse misses its truck because pickers spend too long walking. Another finishes picking on time, but cartons queue at packing. To decide where warehouse automation could help, follow an order from release to loading. For each step, note when the order was ready, when work began and when it ended. The gap before work began shows how long the order waited. The time from start to finish shows how long the step took. Compare those times with other orders on the same truck. If long walks keep slowing the pickers down, bringing totes to their station may help. If picked orders keep waiting for a packer, investigate packing first.
Piece Picking or Full-Pallet Retrieval?
Picking individual items
The system brings a tote to the picking station. The operator takes the requested quantity of each item and sends the completed order to packing.
What to time. Record time spent waiting for totes, picking items and waiting for packing separately. If an empty pick location stops work, record the time spent waiting for replenishment.
Retrieving whole pallets
For a full-pallet order, an automated storage and retrieval system (AS/RS) retrieves the pallet from its storage location and delivers it to the outbound transfer point.
What to check. Count both incoming and outgoing pallets in the busiest hour. Check the pallet dimensions, the weight including the load, and the condition of the pallet base against the equipment specifications.
How Much Must Be Picked Before Dispatch?
An order for two units of each of three different items has three order lines and six units if each item appears on its own line. Give every supplier the same orders and ask how many completed lines the team can deliver to packing per hour.
At 2:00 p.m., 240 orders are ready to pick. They average three lines each, for a total of 720 lines. Count a line only when its full quantity has reached packing. The required team rate depends on the packing deadline.
- All lines at packing by 4:00 p.m.720 lines ÷ 2 hours
- 360 lines/hour
- All lines at packing by 3:30 p.m.720 lines ÷ 1.5 hours
- 480 lines/hour
If most orders become available at 3:00 p.m. and packing needs them by 3:30 p.m., there are only 30 minutes for that work. Count the lines still outstanding at 3:00 p.m. and compare them with the number the team can actually deliver in half an hour. For example, if 300 lines are still due and the team can deliver 240 in the time left, 60 lines are at risk. If the team can deliver all 300, the projected shortfall is zero.
How to Compare Supplier Proposals
Give each supplier the same item list, loaded pallet or tote dimensions and weights, receiving and dispatch layout, and sample orders with their release times. Include both a typical day and a busy one. Agree on the start and finish of each measurement.
- How much fits?
- Ask how many loaded pallets or totes the system can store using your actual load sizes and weights. If locations vary in size, request a count and a weight limit for each type.
- Can it meet the cutoff?
- Measure full-pallet retrieval in pallets per hour and piece picking in completed order lines per hour. Ask which deadlines the system met during the peak test and how much inbound stock it handled at the same time.
- Who connects the systems?
- Identify who will connect the warehouse management system (WMS) to the warehouse control system (WCS) and who will test each pick instruction through to confirmation. Agree which system keeps the inventory record and which events change it.
- What does the price cover?
- Request separate prices for racking, handling equipment, pick stations, installation and systems integration. Separate one-time software charges from recurring fees. Ask which spares and support services are included and which cost extra.
Before comparing rates. One supplier may stop the clock when a tote reaches the pick station, while another waits until the goods reach packing. Ask both to start at order release and count only complete lines delivered to packing.
What to Test Before Handover
Trace a test order
Choose items of different sizes and picking frequencies. Use the labels your team uses on site. Follow a pallet from receipt through storage to retrieval. Check the item codes and quantities against the outbound order, then compare the WMS balance and location with the stock on the floor. For piece picking, time the work from release to delivery at packing against the agreed target.
Test labels and cancellations
Unreadable label. Check that the pallet is held according to the agreed procedure. Correct the label and rescan the same pallet. The WMS should record the quantity actually received just once.
Cancelled outbound order. Choose a released order that nobody has started picking. Cancel the whole order and check that picking stops, the goods stay in place and the reservation is handled as agreed. Record the order reference, expected result, actual result and person responsible for any correction. Repeat the same test before signing it off.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can we keep our existing WMS?
You can keep it if it can send receiving and outbound instructions to the new system and receive complete confirmations. Ask the WMS team and the installer to match each confirmation to its original instruction and check the inventory balance against a physical count. If the two systems use different reference numbers, staff should still be able to trace one to the other.
Resend the same confirmation and check that the inventory changes only once. Then cancel a whole outbound order before picking starts. Verify that picking stops and that the reservation for that order changes as agreed. The results will show which functions need extra work.
Can we start with a single zone?
Yes, if you define where stock enters the zone and where work passes to the next team. Select a traceable group of items and compare orders of similar size and mix before and after installation. Time each order from pick release to packing, including queues and transfers between zones. Before expanding, compare the share of orders ready for their truck on time and the percentage of lines picked incorrectly.
How do we estimate the payback period?
Add the initial equipment, installation and integration costs. At the same workload, subtract the new operating costs from the previous costs to find net annual savings. Include the labour still needed, electricity, software fees and maintenance.
If net savings are positive and roughly constant, use initial investment ÷ net annual savings to get the simple payback period in years. If savings vary, add the net savings year by year until they cover the investment. Repeat the calculation with a lower workload to see how sensitive the result is to demand.

